Proposed Knesset Bill Aims to Tighten Eligibility for Israeli Citizenship

A controversial new bill under consideration in the Israeli Knesset could significantly narrow the criteria for citizenship under the Law of Return, reigniting debates over Jewish identity, national unity, and the relationship between Israel and the broader Jewish world.

The bill, proposed by MK Avi Maoz of the Noam party, would remove the “grandparent clause” from the Law of Return, which has allowed individuals with at least one Jewish grandparent to obtain Israeli citizenship even if they are not Jewish according to halacha (Jewish law). Since 1970, an estimated half a million immigrants have come to Israel under this clause, many from the former Soviet Union.

According to Maoz, the current law “empties the law of its original intention,” asserting that it has enabled non-Jews with tenuous or no connection to Judaism to enter the country. His proposal claims to restore the law’s intent “to open the country’s gates to the Jews of the Diaspora.”

The bill is scheduled to be discussed this Sunday by the Ministerial Committee on Legislation. A favorable ruling would push it forward with official coalition backing. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government, which includes haredi and nationalist factions, has previously floated similar legislation. Haredi parties, in particular, have long opposed the clause, arguing it dilutes the Jewish identity of the state.

However, critics argue that eliminating the clause risks alienating large segments of world Jewry and undermines Israel’s foundational role as a haven for all Jews and their descendants. The clause was originally adopted as a direct response to the Nuremberg Laws, which defined Jews for persecution as anyone with at least one Jewish grandparent.

For many families especially those from the Soviet Union and other regions where Jewish life was brutally suppressed this clause served as a vital lifeline. It offered a chance to reconnect with Jewish heritage and find a home in the Jewish state, despite not meeting Orthodox religious standards.

Supporters of the clause stress its vital role in building Israel’s diverse society and fostering a wide sense of Jewish peoplehood. “We should be welcoming them back into the fold,” said Rabbi Stuart Weinblatt, chairman of the Zionist Rabbinic Coalition. “These individuals are not a threat they are a blessing. They have chosen to cast their lot with the Jewish people and build their lives in Israel.”

While debates over halachic status are not new in Israel, the proposed bill adds fresh urgency to long-standing concerns about inclusivity and unity. It challenges Israel to balance its religious identity with the broader vision of being a homeland for all Jews.

As discussions continue, the proposed change is more than a matter of law it is a test of Israel’s soul, asking whether its gates will remain open to all those who see themselves as part of the Jewish family.

Stay informed and share this article with friends who care about Israel’s future and the global Jewish community. Subscribe to our newsletter for weekly updates.