Controversy Surrounds Pope’s New Book Suggesting Israel Could Be Committing ‘Genocide’

Pope Francis has stirred global controversy with his latest book, Hope Never Disappoints. In it, he suggests an investigation into Israel for a potential “genocide” against Palestinians in Gaza, a claim that has left many Jews and their allies deeply disappointed and concerned.

This accusation comes in the aftermath of Israel’s war against Hamas, a conflict that erupted following the terrorist group’s devastating October 7 massacre in southern Israel. The war is widely seen as Israel’s defensive response to an existential threat. Yet, the pope’s remarks echo a growing trend of vilifying Israel in international discourse, often fueled by unreliable narratives and political opportunism.

The use of the term "genocide" is inflammatory and historically loaded. It conjures images of the Holocaust, a tragedy that left six million Jews murdered. Equating Israel's military actions largely aimed at dismantling Hamas with such atrocities not only undermines the term’s significance but also feeds into a dangerous wave of global antisemitism. Across Europe and beyond, protests have featured swastika-emblazoned signs and cries of “Free Palestine,” often accompanied by overtly anti-Jewish rhetoric. This rhetoric is amplified by world leaders like Turkey’s Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, who has provocatively compared Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to Adolf Hitler.

The statistics cited to justify these accusations against Israel are often dubious. The primary source of Gaza's casualty figures is the Gaza Ministry of Health, controlled by Hamas, which has a vested interest in inflating civilian death tolls. Israel, in contrast, estimates that half of the reported 40,000 fatalities were Hamas combatants, making the civilian-to-combatant casualty ratio among the lowest in modern warfare.

Israel’s extraordinary measures to avoid civilian casualties such as warnings before airstrikes and supplying medical aid to Gaza set it apart from virtually every other nation engaged in wartime operations. Yet, Hamas uses Gaza’s civilian population as human shields, exploiting the inevitable suffering for propaganda. Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar openly admitted this tactic, leveraging the deaths of innocents to bolster international support for their cause.

The genocide accusation also disregards historical context. Since its establishment in 1948, Israel has consistently accepted peace plans and territorial compromises, including the UN’s Partition Plan, the Camp David Accords, and the Oslo Accords. Conversely, Hamas and similar factions have explicitly called for the destruction of Israel and the expulsion of Jews from the region.

It is essential to recognize that the Arab population within Israel has grown exponentially since the nation’s founding, while the Jewish population in Arab nations has dwindled by nearly 99%. Ethnic cleansing occurred in the Middle East, but it was not perpetrated by Israel.

The late Professor Robert Wistrich, a leading historian of antisemitism, described the phenomenon of “Holocaust inversion,” where Jews are falsely cast as oppressors akin to Nazis. This twisted narrative, rooted in Soviet-era propaganda, persists today, threatening to distort public perception and inflame anti-Jewish sentiment.

October 7, 2023, saw a true act of genocidal intent Hamas’s attempt to annihilate Israeli communities. That attempt failed, but the scars of that day remain fresh. The Church should be a voice for truth and peace, not a platform for unsubstantiated accusations that endanger Jewish lives worldwide.

Israel stands firm in its mission: to defend its citizens and uphold the values of democracy, freedom, and humanity in the face of terror. Stand with Israel. Share the truth. Subscribe to our newsletter today.